| Class | Venue | Score | Offensive MVP | Defensive MVP |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 16, East 7 (Recap) | Cole Davis | Riley Carson |
| 2026 | Camping World Stadium | South 44, North 14 (Recap) | Sabby Meassick | Jahbarri Frost |
| 2026 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 22, West 14 (Recap) | Edward Kelly | Jaxson Upper |
| 2025 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 31, West 24 (Recap) | Brodrick Malone | Kam Evans |
| 2025 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | South 31, North 23 (Recap) | Marvin Moore | Braylon Henry |
| 2025 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 41, East 27 (Recap) | Patrick Crayton | Chase Shumate |
| 2024 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 23, East 20 (Recap) | Bodie Derrer | Elijah Green |
| 2024 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 35, East 28 (Recap) | Justice Spann | Alfred Wilkerson |
| 2024 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | South 41, North 31 (Recap) | Truitt Brown | Terrance Weatherspoon |
| 2023 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 37, East 17 (Recap) | Aidan Armenta | Brent Hoppe |
| 2023 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 20, East 13 (Recap) | Drew Cowart | Nolan DeLong |
| 2023 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | North 42, South 26 (Recap) | Cortney Davis | Barrett Newman |
| 2022 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 35, West 27 (Recap) | Seth Cromwell | Jace Sifore |
| 2022 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 27, West 23 (Recap) | Kai Kunz | Drew Logan |
| 2022 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | North 34, South 27 (Recap) | Tyler Vroman | Davion Williams |
| 2021 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 42, West 29 (Recap) | Zachary Mitchell | Kevin Tinsley |
| 2021 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 52, East 42 (Recap) | ShunDerrick Powell | Emari Pait |
| 2021 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 25, West 24 (Recap) | Seth Smith | Donovan Adkins |
| 2021 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 36, West 17 (Recap) | Shane Hamm | C.J. Taylor |
| 2020 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 37, East 30 (Recap) | Austin Bolt | Walker Baty |
| 2020 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | South 16, North 10 (Recap) | Rent Montie | Jeremiah Wright |
| 2020 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 45, East 15 (Recap) | Andrew Brister | Ben Furtney |
| 2020 | Falcons' Mercedes Benz Stadium | Grey 27, Blue 20 (Recap) | Kyle Toole | Quinn Urwiler |
| 2019 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 40, East 34 (Recap) | Cooper Legas | Isiah Brown-Dietzman |
| 2019 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | North 20, South 12 (Recap) | Grayson McCall | Etinosa Rueben |
| 2019 | Texans' NRG Stadium | Lone Star 29, Forty-Nine 10 (Recap) | Garrison Johnson | Gianni Rizzo |
| 2019 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 26, West 7 (Recap) | Velton Gardner | Trey Vaval |
| 2018 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | North 14, South 13 (Recap) | Johnny Ford | Noah Palmer |
| 2018 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 23, East 20 (Recap) | Connor Noland | John Graves |
| 2018 | Jaguars' EverBank Field | Grey 31, Blue 28 (Recap) | Mychale Salahuddin | Isaiah Lee |
| 2018 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | East 28, West 17 (Recap) | Billy Maples | Marcell Ellis |
| 2017 | Jaguars' EverBank Field | Grey 27, Blue 7 (Recap) | Amari Terry | Joshua Maize |
| 2017 | Oakland Raiders' Coliseum | Pacific 37, Atlantic 14 (Recap) | Chase Cord | Myles Cecil |
| 2017 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 27, East 24 (Recap) | Terence Dunlap | Kris McCune |
| 2016 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | North 35, South 0 (Recap) | J.J. Taylor | Robert Green |
| 2016 | Jaguars' EverBank Field | Grey 28, Blue 14 (Recap) | Jalen Starks | Troy Pride |
| 2016 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 21, East 14 (Recap) | James Robinson | Madre Harper |
| 2015 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | South 39, North 14 (Recap) | Willie Parker | Brett Zanotto |
| 2015 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 7, East 6 (Recap) | Jalen McCleskey | Avery Anderson |
| 2014 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | South 47, North 44 (Recap) | Keith Harrington | Tre Watson |
| 2014 | Cowboys' AT&T Stadium | West 41, East 7 (Recap) | Vic Enwere | Lonnie Johnson |
| 2013 | Bucs' Raymond James Stadium | South 21, North 14 (Recap) | Byron Pringle | Michael McGinnis |
